Driver in Paramus bus crash had license suspended 14 times; six for unpaid parking tickets
The reported driver of the Paramus school bus that collided with a dump truck last week on Route 80, leaving two dead, has a long history of tickets, moving violations and license suspensions, the New Jersey Motor Vehicle Commission confirmed Tuesday.
The bus driver, Hudy Muldrow, 77, of Paterson, has had his license suspended 14 times since he began driving in 1975, said Mairin Bellack, a commission spokesperson. Muldrow has eight speeding tickets on his record, as well as one careless driving ticket and a summons for unsafe operation of a motor vehicle, from 2003, Bellack said.
Six license suspensions were due to unpaid parking tickets, including Muldrow’s most recent, which lasted from Dec. 20, 2017 to Jan. 3, 2018. The state also once suspended his commercial driver’s license for administrative reasons, Bellack said.
Muldrow, whom a source identified Tuesday as the driver, was ferrying dozens of East Brook Middle School fifth graders on a field trip to Waterloo Village, a historic 19th century canal tow, when Thursday's accident occurred in Morris County.
Hudy Muldrow Jr., Muldrow's son, was the first to reportedly identify his father in the crash. He declined to comment Tuesday about the crash.
Muldrow appears to have missed the village's highway exit, and was possibly attempting a U-turn on a police turnaround near Exit 25 in Mount Olive when the dump truck hit it, a source said. The crash killed Miranda Vargas, 10, and Jennifer Marie Williamson Kennedy, 51, and injured 43 others.
Many of those injured have been released from area hospitals, including Hackettstown Medical Center. But those with the most serious injuries remain.
Muldrow's license is valid, according to the Motor Vehicle Commission. But it remains unclear what charges, if any, he could face for the accident.
BUSES:NTSB recommends that NJ equip its school buses with shoulder belts
MIRANDA VARGAS:Funeral held for fifth-grader killed in crash
JENNIFER WILLIAMSON:Popular teacher who died in crash was devoted to students
According to the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration, which oversees Commercial Driver's License regulations, he could lose his CDL for a year if he’s convicted of negligent driving that results in a fatality.
The Morris County Prosecutor's Office is handling the investigation, but has been exceptionally tight-lipped about its findings. No new information has been released since Friday.
Though investigators have not announced charges or moving violations relating to the crash, both Muldrow and the school board that employs him could face a civil suit.
David Fried, the Vargas family’s attorney, said Tuesday he was investigating a possible legal basis for a lawsuit.
“One would simply be for the negligent operation by the bus driver,” Fried said. “He was their employee so they will be responsible for his negligence.”
But some cautioned against rushing to judgment about the accident’s cause, regardless of Muldrow’s prior record or his age.
“Presumably, if he can maintain a CDL, he was passing all the qualifications,” said Steve Carrellas, head of the state chapter of the National Motorists Association. “If everything was OK, this is just one of those things that clearly could have been avoided, even after the missed exit … it was just bad judgment."
READ MORE:Why was Paramus school bus crash so violent?
READ MORE:Paramus families pray and seek solace after tragedy
Muldrow needed a commercial driver’s license to legally drive a school bus. And he had met the host of necessary medical and physical requirements, like having at least 20/40 vision in each eye (with or without corrective lenses), 70 degrees of peripheral vision in each eye and the ability to recognize red, green and amber colors.
Applicants must pass a criminal history background check to get a CDL. And federal law requires school bus drivers to always carry a signed medical examiner’s fitness statement, which is to be renewed every two years. Bus drivers are also required to obtain passenger and school bus endorsements, which verify the background and health information.
Drivers must be at least 21 years old with three years of driving experience to get a CDL. Although there is no mandatory retirement age, the commission can suspend a driver’s endorsement for many reasons, including the discovery of a medical issue, a criminal history or a poor driving record.
Despite his previous record, Muldrow had no active points on his license, the commission said.