3 New Jersey spots make the list of 'America's 100 Most Charming Main Streets'

Amelia Earhart and her strange New Jersey connection

Kaitlyn Kanzler
NorthJersey

The 80th anniversary of Amelia Earhart's disappearance recently passed, and a new theory has surfaced about what happened to her as she attempted to become the first woman to circumnavigate the globe.

Amelia Earhart and her navigator, Fred Noonan, in front of their twin-engine Lockheed Electra in Los Angeles at the end of May 1937.

Earhart and her navigator, Fred Noonan, disappeared over the Pacific Ocean on July 2, 1937, many people believing she ran out of gas and crashed into the water.

A new documentary on the History Channel claims that a photograph found deep within the National Archives shows the famed lost pilot and Noonan captured by the Japanese on the Marshall Islands.

There have been many theories over the years, including one that Earhart had returned to the United States and was a housewife in New Jersey.

In the 1970s, a book called "Amelia Earhart Lives" by Joe Klass was published, claiming that Irene Bolam, a woman living in Monroe Township in Middlesex County, was the lost pilot.

PHOTO FOUND: New photo may prove Amelia Earhart was captured by the Japanese

AMELIA EARHART: This is why the mystery endures 80 years later

According to Richard Gillespie, founder and executive director of The International Group for Historic Aircraft Recovery [TIGHAR], someone saw Bolam at a garden party on Long Island and thought her to be Earhart. Bolam denied she was the female aviator, but Klass's book claimed that Earhart returned to the United States after World War II to live a different life as a New Jersey housewife. Bolam happened to bear a slight resemblance to Earhart and was also a pilot.

Bolam sued Klass and McGraw-Hill after the book was published and received a settlement of an unknown amount. The publisher pulled the books from the shelves.

"People will believe anything," Gillespie said.

The new History Channel documentary, premiering Sunday, claims the unearthed photograph depicts Earhart and Noonan on a dock while their Lockheed Electra 10E is towed by a boat and that the two were captured by the Japanese military and held until their deaths.

Gillespie called the theory an "absolute myth" and "ridiculous."

"It's a person who might be a white woman in the distance sitting on the edge of a dock and a guy that looks like a white guy, so it has to be them," Gillespie said. "It's ridiculous."

Gillespie pointed out that the hair of the person sitting on the dock is too long to be Earhart's and that there are no Japanese soldiers surrounding her and her navigator.

"If that's Amelia Earhart, where are the soldiers? No one is carrying a gun; no one is restricting their activity," Gillespie said, adding that it is hard to believe that Earhart was captured by the Japanese and the United States knew about it. "Think about how many people would have to keep that secret for years."

TIGHAR has made several expeditions to Nikumaroro, which was formerly known as Gardner Island, in the Pacific, where he believes he has found evidence that Earhart and Noonan crashed there and became castaways. TIGHAR is currently wrapping up an expedition on Nikumaroro to find human remains with National Geographic and forensic cadaver dogs.

Much of the evidence found on Nikumaroro through numerous TIGHAR expeditions points to Noonan and Earhart dying as castaways, Gillespie said. According to the executive director, the theory that the two perished on the island is the original theory. It makes perfect sense to Gillespie that Earhart died on the island, noting that Nikumaroro was along the same navigation line as their original destination and that distress calls from Earhart's plane were transmitting from that area for six days after her disappearance. Gillespie said it took the Navy a week to reach the island to search for Earhart, and by that time the plane had been washed off the reef, slipping into the waves below. They thought the distress calls were a hoax and surmised that the plane crashed into the ocean, he said.

Three years after Earhart disappeared, the British established a colony on the island and discovered the partial skeleton of a castaway. Part of a woman's shoe was found, as well as a sextant, used for navigation, Gillespie said.

Photographic evidence of Amelia Earhart and Fred Noonan in the Marshall Islands found in the National Archives.

The British thought it could be Earhart and notified authorities in Fiji. They secretly sent the bones and the sextant to them and misidentified them, and the bones were thrown away. Gillespie said TIGHAR has found the original documents in an archive in London, and they found the grave on the island.

"We've examined it archaeologically, and we are finding artifacts that speak to an American woman in the 1930s," Gillespie said. "We are trying to find any surviving human remains to get DNA."

TIGHAR is also searching for the remains of Earhart's plane, which Gillespie maintains are in an area of steep coral reef that makes searching difficult.

Amelia Earhart poses in this undated photo.